Sam Edwards, Carole Mathews, and "Superman" serial - Serial Report

Search the Western Clippings Site

An Interview With…
        - Archives

Will "Sugarfoot" Hutchins
    - Archives

Do You Remember?
    - Archives

Comic Book Cowboys
    - Archives

Westerns of...
    - Archives

Heavies and Characters
      - Archives

The Stuntmen - Neil Summers
    - Archives

Western Treasures
    - Archives

Circus Cowboys
    - Archives

Radio Range Riders
    - Archives

Rangeland Elegance
    - Archives

Western Artifacts
    - Archives

Film Festival Fotos
    - Archives

Silent Western Reviews
    - Archives

Serial Report
    - Chapter 128
    - Chapter 127
    - Chapter 126
    - Chapter 125
    - Chapter 124
    - Chapter 123
    - Chapter 122
    - Chapter 121
    - Chapter 120
    - Chapter 119
    - Chapter 118
    - Chapter 117
    - Chapter 116
    - Chapter 115
    - Chapter 114
    - Chapter 113
    - Chapter 112
    - Chapter 111
    - Chapter 110
    - Chapter 109
    - Chapter 108
    - Chapter 107
    - Chapter 106
    - Chapter 105
    - Chapter 104
    - Chapter 103
    - Chapter 102
    - Chapter 101
    - Chapter One Hundred
    - Chapter Ninety-Nine
    - Chapter Ninety-Eight
    - Chapter Ninety-Seven
    - Chapter Ninety-Six
    - Chapter Ninety-Five
    - Chapter Ninety-Four
    - Chapter Ninety-Three
    - Chapter Ninety-Two
    - Chapter Ninety-One
    - Chapter Ninety
    - Chapter Eighty-Nine
    - Chapter Eighty-Eight
    - Chapter Eighty-Seven
    - Chapter Eighty-Six
    - Chapter Eighty-Five
    - Chapter Eighty-Four
    - Chapter Eighty-Three
    - Chapter Eighty-Two
    - Chapter Eighty-One
    - Chapter Eighty
    - Chapter Seventy-Nine
    - Chapter Seventy-Eight
    - Chapter Seventy-Seven
    - Chapter Seventy-Six
    - Chapter Seventy-Five
    - Chapter Seventy-Four
    - Chapter Seventy-Three
    - Chapter Seventy-Two
    - Chapter Seventy-One
    - Chapter Seventy
    - Chapter Sixty-Nine
    - Chapter Sixty-Eight
    - Chapter Sixty-Seven
    - Chapter Sixty-Six
    - Chapter Sixty-Five
    - Chapter Sixty-Four
    - Chapter Sixty-Three
    - Chapter Sixty-Two
    - Chapter Sixty-One
    - Chapter Sixty
    - Chapter Fifty-Nine
    - Chapter Fifty-Eight
    - Chapter Fifty-Seven
    - Chapter Fifty-Six
    - Chapter Fifty-Five
    - Chapter Fifty-Four
    - Chapter Fifty-Three
    - Chapter Fifty-Two
    - Chapter Fifty-One
    - Chapter Fifty
    - Chapter Forty-Nine
    - Chapter Forty-Eight
    - Chapter Forty-Seven
    - Chapter Forty-Six
    - Chapter Forty-Five
    - Chapter Forty-Four
    - Chapter Forty-Three
    - Chapter Forty-Two
    - Chapter Forty-One
    - Chapter Forty
    - Chapter Thirty-Nine
    - Chapter Thirty-Eight
    - Chapter Thirty-Seven
    - Chapter Thirty-Six
    - Chapter Thirty-Five
    - Chapter Thirty-Four
    - Chapter Thirty-Three
    - Chapter Thirty-Two
    - Chapter Thirty-One
    - Chapter Thirty
    - Chapter Twenty-Nine
    - Chapter Twenty-Eight
    - Chapter Twenty-Seven
    - Chapter Twenty-Six
    - Chapter Twenty-Five
    - Chapter Twenty-Four
    - Chapter Twenty-Three
    - Chapter Twenty-Two
    - Chapter Twenty-One
    - Chapter Twenty
    - Chapter Nineteen
    - Chapter Eighteen
    - Chapter Seventeen
    - Chapter Sixteen
    - Chapter Fifteen
    - Chapter Fourteen
    - Chapter Thirteen
    - Chapter Twelve
    - Chapter Eleven
    - Chapter Ten
    - Chapter Nine
    - Chapter Eight
    - Chapter Seven
    - Chapter Six
    - Chapter Five
    - Chapter Four
    - Chapter Three
    - Chapter Two
    - Chapter One

Subscribe to Western Clippings


Western Clippings Back Issues

Daily Comic Strips
    - Page 1 (1910-1949)
    - Page 2 (1950-1979)

Sunday Comic Strips
    - 1907-1990


Miscellaneous Collectibles


Lobby Cards

Movie Posters


Chapter Two

Sam Edwards reflects on his work as Chuck in the Dave O’Brien serial, “Captain Midnight” (Col. ‘42) filmed at the Larry Darmour Studios on Santa Monica Blvd. near Gower.

“I had a lot of fun on it. We did 15 episodes in six weeks. I did all of the stunts: the run-throughs, the falling into traps, crashing cars through barricades and so forth, and I was not aware they had a double for me. This little fellow kept following me around and saying, ‘Do you want me to do this for you?’ I said, ‘No, I can drive.’ After the picture, I kept getting extra checks. I found out later I was getting all the stunt checks. This poor guy, I was doing him out of his stunt checks. Anyway, I could use the money because they didn’t pay very much in those days,” Sam laughed.

Sam Edwards (L) as Chuck and Guy Wilkerson (R) as Ichabod Mudd confront two heavies in Episode 3 of "Captain Midnight" ('42 Columbia).

“We had a scene in one of the episodes where the heavies had us in a shack and we had a free-for-all fight. The set catches on fire and they just kept on filming.  The heavy was supposed to let me hit him, but it wasn’t supposed to look like he is letting me. He said, ‘Go ahead, I can dodge it.’ I said, ‘I can hit you with a near miss,’ and he said, ‘No, try and hit me, we want this to look good.’ I’m supposed to give him a hay-maker, but during the fight a guy got behind him so he couldn’t back up, and I hauled off from the floor and hit him and knocked him out. It almost broke my hand. That kind of unnerved me a bit.” (Probably Ch. 2 or Ch. 8…altho no fire exists here. Possibly, Edwards is getting various fights intermingled in his memory after nearly 60 years—ed.)

“But, I tell you, they had us driving through barricades and falling into traps in false floors…it was a lot of fun. I hit a barricade in an automobile. It was a breakaway, but it didn’t break. We kind of laughed about that. It didn’t do the car any good though. I was young and daring, and I sort of enjoyed it.”

Sam paid tribute to the star, Dave O’Brien. “He was a real nice guy, later became a writer,  wrote a lot of things for the ‘Red Skelton Show’.”

“I have never seen one episode of ‘Captain Midnight’. I was drafted about a week after we finished the last episode.”

Sam Edwards graciously sigend this photo for me of himself, Dave O'Brien as Captain Midnight and Guy Wilkerson as Ichabod Mudd.

In 1999 Sam Edwards was presented a Life Achievement Award for his years of work as a radio actor by the Radio Enthusiasts of Puget Sound in Seattle. “I was so flattered because I was among some very, very talented people.”

Sam Edwards, 89, died July 28, 2004, of a heart attack in Durango, CO.

With aspirations early in life to be a nun, it was at the dare of school classmates to put on a bathing suit and enter the Miss Chicago contest that changed the direction of life for beautiful Carole Mathews.

“From one extreme to the other,” she laughs. “I was qualified to try for Miss America in 1938, but my parents said absolutely not. But winning the title of Miss Chicago, I won a screen test and a trip to California. My grandmother went with me.”

“I read where Earl Carroll was advertising for showgirls, and being 5'7", I thought I would qualify. I didn’t know what a showgirl really was. (Laughs) I tried out but Carroll said no, because I had a tan and he wanted all his girls white. You used to have to wear white makeup. He said, if you can lose your tan in two weeks, I’ll hire you. So for two weeks, my grandmother and I would get lemon and put it in the bath water and I’d rub lemon all over my body to try and lose the tan. I lost it enough that he hired me.”

The girl born Jean Diefel 9/13/20 in Montgomery, IL, (a suburb of Aurora) was now in showbiz. Her entrance into films was under the name Jeanne Francis (“Romance In the Dark”, “Girl From Avenue A”, “Footlight Serenade”).

Carole signed with Columbia in late ‘43. “I didn’t like Harry Cohn and he didn’t like me at all. I was more scared of him than anything. He had roughness. Anybody that was rough, I kind of closed up. He didn’t chase me. (As he was known to do.) I didn’t get that far. I was really kind of independent. I liked Max Arno, the talent person at Columbia. I think he was the one that decided to put me under contract.

Carole’s early Columbia work includes “Girl In the Case”, “She’s a Sweetheart”, “Missing Juror”, “Blazing the Overland Trail” and “Outlaws of the Rockies” (w/Charles Starrett), “I Love a Mystery” and others…16 films total in ‘44-‘45. Plus her role as Babs Arnold, Ralph Morgan’s daughter, in Columbia’s 15 chapter “thrill serial of a mechanical monster gone mad”, “The Monster  and the Ape” with Robert Lowery.

Ray Corrigan as the Ape of Columbia's "Monster and the Ape" serial ('45) holds an unconcious Carole Mathews while fending off Ralph Morgan as Professor Arnold (Carole's father) and Robert Lowery as heroic Ken Morgan.

“That was fun to do,” Carole smiles. “It was like not really going to work. It was fun. Like it wasn’t really a movie. I was in a couple of pictures with George Macready.” (Evil Prof. Ernst in the serial.)

Shortly after, Carole ended her contract at Columbia. “I had a run-in with the head hairdresser at Columbia. She’s the one that got me fired.”

Carole continued to freelance in A and B films and had a regular role on TV’s “The Californians” in 1958.

Carole always loved to travel and began to do more as work became less, eventually opening her own travel agency. “In all my travels, one thing I’ve found out is to be more patient and understanding with people I don’t understand. I stop and analyze—where do they come from, why are they that way?”

"Monster and the Ape" ad.Later, Carole began to raise miniature horses. “In 1982, I was the top champion winner of miniature horses. High points. I had a grand champion mare and a champion stallion. I also had ducks and goats…I love animals.”

Plagued by various illnesses for years, Carole is once again in good health. “I’m on my third pacemaker. I was ill for about ten years. I had a stroke, I had cancer, I had a new hip replacement. I’m not finished yet. I’ve got some unfinished business to do. I enjoy my life.” In retirement, Carole lives today in Murrieta, California.

Viewing the Columbia cliffhanger “Superman” so late in my serial watching career was not unlike finally seeing Lee Powell as “The Lone Ranger” in the Republic chapterplay or catching Barry Nelson as James Bond in an early TV adaptation of “Casino Royale,” both now available on video. Having grown up on a steady diet of Clayton Moore and Sean Connery in these same roles, their image was simply too strong, too indelibly etched in my mind to allow my being totally fair to their predecessors. The same is even truer in the case of Krypton’s number one son.

For the million other Baby Boomers who sat mesmerized in front of their black and white TVs in the early ‘50s,  there will always be only one genuine Superman, George Reeves. Other actors might have borrowed the famous red and blue costume on occasion, people like Christopher Reeve and Dean Cain, but in the minds of millions—myself included—only George Reeves was the real thing.

For this reason, I had to do some serious mental preparation in order to watch the Columbia serial and not unduly pre-judge it or allow small unflattering comparisons to the beloved TV show to cloud my opinion. This wasn’t often easy.

To be fair, this is not quite the incredibly inept, bottom of the barrel serial I had—thanks to years of negative comments from many quarters—braced myself for (unlike “Batman and Robin” which pretty much lived up to grim expectations). It is indeed cheaply produced with the usual Sam Katzman corner cutting, inadequately crafted and not always expertly paced, but still I had a pretty good time with it.

It’s played very broadly—even by serial standards—but for the most part this is okay. After awhile, even Superman’s live action leaps into the sky which instantly turned into cartoon representations of the soaring character didn’t bother me as much as I thought they might have. Given the myriad of acrobatic things the writers expected him to accomplish in flight, there was simply no other  way to economically do it. The Captain Marvel and Rocketman dummies at Republic propelled over a line looked great for what they did, but their motion was severely limited and could never have emulated the sort of arobatics Superman’s travels were intended to depict.

Plotwise, once Superman gets to Earth (the first chapter predictably recounts his origins on the doomed planet Krypton), he finds work as Clark Kent at the Daily Planet and is soon battling a gang led by evil femme fatale the Spider Lady (played by lovely serial veteran Carol Forman who, for some reason, wears a God-awful blonde wig through most of the proceedings).

Kent’s colleagues at the paper are boss Perry White (Pierre Watkin), Jimmy Olsen (Tommy Bond) and Lois Lane (Noel Neill’s first outing as the character she would later play on television after Phyllis Coates regrettably left the role.)

Noel Neill as Lois Lane and Tommy Bond as Jimmy Olsen stare in amazement as the Spider Lady (Carol Forman) and her henchman George Meeker seem to have defeated Superman (Kirk Alyn).

Ms. Neill, with her long hair, appears a good deal younger here, more collegiate and preppy. The fact she sports a hat which looks something like an enlarged slice of pita bread, doesn’t help her rather bratty image. She’s a bit spunkier and more confrontational than when she played the character on the small screen and doesn’t for an instant relinquish her intense dislike of Clark Kent, a dislike which seems more to border on loathing than merely professional rivalry (apparently the actress felt pretty much the same way about the actor in real life).

The late Kirk Alyn, not unexpectedly, is my real problem—just as I thought he would be—so let me get this major gripe out of the way then move on. It seems to me there are two ways to play Superman. George Reeves, due to the different styles and approaches of his TV producers, Robert Maxwell and Whitney Ellsworth, had a go at both: stoic, taciturn and no-nonsense crimefighter (first season) and later avuncular, caring, wise but powerful protector of the weak and needful for the remainder of the show’s run. Alyn, however, ignores both of these roads. His interpretation is highly exaggerated, almost arrogant, something no serial hero should ever be. The way he postures and poses reminds me of all those strutting, gleeful musclemen  who played the role of Hercules after the more subdued Steve Reeves vacated the part. He struts about, puffs out the “S” on his chest, grins too much, and comes off as more bully than savior—and not a very bright one at that. Perhaps directors Thomas Carr and Spencer Bennet, as well as writer George Plympton, had a hand in this. Perhaps no thought to subtlety was given when bringing this comic book character to the big screen.  (One has to wonder how Republic, who had first rights to the character, would have envisioned the part). As  said in an earlier column, I have enjoyed Alyn in other roles where his performance wasn’t so exaggerated or over the top (“Daughter of Don Q” as an example). But in this instance, I found him nothing short of annoying and a real turnoff. Most of the time I rooted for the bad guys!

Speaking of the heavies, the supporting cast is the usual Columbia gang of thugs and stupid henchman, not only old pros like Jack Ingram, Charles King, George Meeker and Terry Frost, but one-time serial good guy CharlesQuigley as a villain this time around, none of whom, to be honest, appear much up to the task of offering a serious threat to the Man of Steel (actually, in this version I’m not so certain about the steel part since the villains never seem to hurt their mitts when they punch out Clark Kent).

The Spider Lady's henchmen offer little threat to the Man of Steel.

What’s needed here is a bigger than life villain (which the Spider Lady is assuredly not), a more dynamic storyline and some better cliffhangers. I know this serial was popular and financially successful at the time and it prompted a sequel, the slightly more enjoyable “Atom Man Vs. Superman”(‘51), but for the most part, viewed nearly a half a century later, I couldn’t help finding it, unlike so many of the classic serials I still very much enjoy, a rather tame, bland and not particularly satisfying experience. It didn’t annoy or necessarily bore me…and there were actually moments I found myself enjoying… it’s just that there weren’t enough of them to support a storyline built around a character as normally exciting and mythical as the mighty Superman.